I’m currently running a D&D game in the Final Fantasy XIV world setting using a modified version of the excellent FFXIV x DND homebrew. At its core, it’s still D&D 5e, but I’ve been taking the opportunities the setting gives me to tweak and open up some of the systems to fit the more modular and open gaming style I tend to enjoy. I already wrote one article about the Point Buy Feats system I created to give my players more diverse options. Today I want to drop my setup for removing a ton of complexity from the D&D item system.
Why Change Things?
I’ve always had a few personal issues with the way money and currency are handled in D&D games. I played way back when, in the days of 2e, and I get where the system has its historical roots. It works fine, but it always feels off. Whether it’s bribing a guard with what would be a year’s salary or realizing that the prices this “poor blacksmith” is selling their goods for should result in them living in opulent wealth, it just never seems to add up in a way that is quite understandable. If the tech level differs a bit or there are more advanced options in the world, the system feels even more off balance. Sure, you just handwave and move along so you can get to the fun parts of the game, but I’ve always felt there are better ways.
I’ve tried using skill and resource based systems like in old World of Darkness games, and I’ve dipped into not bothering with it at all and just pushing those elements to the narrative. The issue always comes back to the players wanting to have that ‘gaining money’ experience, and it’s hard to do that without some quantification of the resource. It’s rarely satisfying to say “The quest giver offers you a ‘good amount of money’ to do this job” and then move on. Would the characters be motivated beyond the danger? Would they want more? How much more should they negotiate for? Would they scoff and not take the danger on for that paltry sum? So, from a narrative perspective, money needs at least a little definition to create the experience that fits the scope of D&D games. Really, all games in any setting need some sort of conceptualization of money if it is at all a part of the tropes. Would the elite merc group take on the deadly mission for $500? Would the tramp freighter group try to run the imperial blockade for 4,000 credits? Without some concept of relative worth, some of the verisimilitude breaks down, but the super detailed and accurate item accounting can cause it’s own issues and be a pain to keep track of. So, what’s the solution?
I’ve played around with lots of ways to get around the issues I find in the D&D currency system, but the one that resonates and seems to fix most of my issues is figuring out the relative costs for some important categories and providing an adequate range for items of that type. Making a kind of matrix of value in the game world. Having the range of costs for a basic category gives you enough flexibility to quickly figure out a price for almost anything, while also allowing you to vary up things based on market conditions.
Here are my relative costs for my FFXIVxDND game. Everything is converted to GIL for my world, but if you wanted to convert this back to stock D&D quickly consider using the silver standard. You could just change Gil to Silver and tweak as needed to fit your own pricing desires. The “Silver Standard” paradigm is a popular way to re-conceptualize and make the D&D prices feel more understandable. It dovetails nicely enough with the Gil. I’m always a fan of a named currency rather than currency being a standardized piece of a precious metal.
Basic Goods (In Gil)
|Cost Range (Gil)||Mundane Item||Ammunition
|Adventuring Gear||Apothecary /
|Cheap||1 – 10 Gil||1 Gil||1 – 20 Gil||10 – 30 Gil|
|Moderate||10 – 30 Gil||1 – 2 Gil||30 – 75 Gil||30 – 150 Gil|
|Expensive||30 – 75 Gil||3 – 5 Gil||75 – 300 Gil||150 – 500 Gil|
|Very Expensive||75 – 150 Gil||6 – 40 Gil||300 – 1,000 Gil||500 – 2,000 Gil|
|Extravagant||150 – 1,000 Gil||40 – 100 Gil||1,000 – 5,000 Gil||2,000 – 5,000 Gil|
Lifestyle (In Gil)
|Cost Range (Gil)||Food and Drink
|Food and Drink
|Lifestyle / Pay
|Lifestyle / Salary
|Cheap||5 – 15 Gil||2 – 4 Gil||20 – 40 Gil||10 – 30 Gil||300 – 900 Gil|
|Moderate||15 – 30 Gil||6 – 12 Gil||40 – 80 Gil||30 – 80 Gil||900 – 2,400 Gil|
|Expensive||30 – 60 Gil||12 – 20 Gil||80 – 150 Gil||80 – 120 Gil||2,400 – 3,600 Gil|
|Very Expensive||60 – 100 Gil||20 – 40 Gil||150 – 300 Gil||120 – 200 Gil||3,600 – 6,000 Gil|
|Extravagant||100 – 200 Gil||40 – 60 Gil||300 – 500 Gil||200 – 500 Gil||6,000 – 15,000 Gil|
Travel (In Gil, Per person)
|Distance||Cart / Mount||Boat||Airship||Aetheryte|
|Short||10 – 30 Gil||30 – 60 Gil||80 – 100 Gil||150 – 300 Gil|
|Moderate||30 – 50 Gil||60 – 100 Gil||100 – 300 Gil||300 – 600 Gil|
|Far||50 – 200 Gil||100 – 250 Gil||300 – 500 Gil||600 – 900 Gil|
|Very Far||200 – 400 Gil||250 – 500 Gil||500 – 900 Gil||900 – 1500 Gil|
|Extreme||400 – 1000 Gil||500 – 900 Gil||900 – 1,200+ Gil||1,500+ Gil|
Special / Magic Item General Price
Modified from the DMG chart, magic item prices will vary greatly depending on usage. This chart is for general consideration only.
|Common||1st or higher||–||100 – 500 Gil|
|Uncommon||1st or higher||–||500 -5,000 Gil|
|Rare||5th or higher||+1||5,000 – 50,000 Gil|
|Very rare||11th or higher||+2||50,00 – 250,000 Gil|
|Legendary||17th or higher||+3||250,000+ Gil|
The Breakdown – Or what’s so great about this?
What I love about this setup is that I can instantly ditch set item prices. I have converted a lot of the D&D items to Gil within this paradigm, but when it comes down to figuring out how much some item should cost that isn’t listed, I’ve got some lines I can color within. Maybe a player gets a very smart idea to bribe the librarian for the arcanum they need access to with a super nice journal or a rare book. All I have to do is consider what category it is within – let’s say low range of extravagant – and give the player some options. Perhaps give them a choice between a journal bound in rare leather and transported from a far away land for about 180 gil or a tome of Ben Hur 1860, third edition with the erratum on page 116 for only 376 gil. Both rare books, simple enough to figure out a price without referencing the item lists and then trying to determine how much it might be based off of standard D&D.
Book prices aren’t written up anywhere I know of in the stock D&D setting, and their value may change depending on setting and the rarity. With the relative system in place, all I have to do is decide if they are common or extravagant and decide how much this area may have one available for. Take a common item such as a set of blacksmith’s tools. I could determine that it is cheaper in a more populous area (say 65 gil for a hammer and tongs) while in a frontier outpost it costs more (125 gil) because of lack of supply and demand. I just have to target what I want the cost to represent for the item. Working with ranges lets you be flexible.
As you can see from the breakdowns I wrote up, you can also create ranges for many different types of sellable items or services. Modifying lifestyle options lets you get a general idea of how much a good bribe might be or how much fancy meals would cost within the range. With travel I can make the categories representative rather than 3 gil per mile and have to figure out the math. I can also break out of the ranges for special circumstances. Sure, it’s only a short travel by airship or boat but the island is supposed to be haunted and the captain requires triple the pay per person.
The Real Handwave – Real World Pricing
One more thing I like to do to ease things even more is make things equivalent to common scope of real world items. Matching what you and your players understand as real world value in USD, CAD, Euro, Rands, Yen, etc. and building the categories based off of that will let you just come up with prices immediately. You could even shift your money system by an amount if you wanted to make it feel unique but still match a common understanding of value. If something would cost 20 dollars USD you could decide it is around 200 gil in the game setting because everything is about 10x real world prices in gil. Something that wouldn’t be mass manufactured may accommodate the hand crafting cost, but – if you match to real world money paradigms, much easier to figure things out. if you don’t, and you set up your relative price ranges well you can still easily grok general costs. You may look up hand made soap on Etsy and see people sell it for around 4 to 6 bucks per piece. Great – that’s 4 gil to 6 gil or 400 gil to 600 gil if you are shifting prices for a unique feeling.
This is not a system based in realism, except where it is. Maybe it’s more true to say it isn’t a system based in exacts, but neither are real world money systems. Look almost anything up on amazon or any similar marketplace and you’ll see pricing varies greatly for goods that are made by multiple different manufacturers. The same goods also cost different prices in different locations. Anything on an island is usually more expensive because of supply chain costs and buying something from an open air market compared to an established shop will see great variation in the costs. This is a system more about defining the value than the exacts, and that can be incredibly freeing. The paradigm works across many settings and it becomes easy to shift and move when the current game situation requires it.
What do you think about relative money systems like this? Do you see yourself using something like this to ease some bookkeeping? What other categories would you create to accommodate your in-game needs?