After nearly 18 months, my Blades In The Dark game is coming to a close. Our table selected Xcrawl Classics as our next game. While I love learning and playing new games, as someone who is neurodivergent, I hate giving up my established systems for how I run my game. Not only do I need to learn a new set of rules and setting, but I also have to build a new workflow for prep and campaign management, as well as templates for my prep. I’ll walk you through how I work through this process. 

It starts by understanding the three areas of consideration for any game…

What The Game Needs

Before we go through the process, we need to recognize that each game has certain things it needs in order to prep, run, and manage the game. Some games will need battlemats and tokens, others will need the management of decks of cards, some will have dice, some will need reference tables. The rulebook for the game should tell you what it needs in order to play the game.

What You Need

Moving beyond the needs of the game, there is what you need as a GM in order to be comfortable enough to run the game. This could be your own cheat sheets, a GM screen, initiative tracker, something to take session notes with, etc. You may want to run this from print media only, or from a laptop, or online, etc. This is going to be somewhat influenced by the game but more strongly influenced by your personal GMing style and needs as well as any accommodations you want for yourself.

What The Table Needs

Finally, moving out beyond your personal needs, the table may need certain things. They will need some kind of character sheet or tracker. They may need their own cheat sheets, reference books, cards, minis, etc. They may need a battlemap for keeping track of things. They may want a place to archive their session notes.

These three areas combined will create a set of needs/demands for what you will need to consider and prepare for your new game. 

How I Prepare

The sections below are more discrete and in order than how I normally think about this. That is done for ease of readability. In truth, I go over this in more of a mind-map fashion with various branches running off in all sorts of directions. But for your sanity and Bob’s (Gnome Stew’s Editor), I present it to you like this… 

Learn the Rules and Setting

One of my first activities is to get into the rulebook and learn the game. I will eventually read the entire book, but by my first pass through the rules I look for three things:

  • The Core Loop – what is it that the PCs do in this game? Does the game define it, or do I need to work that out with the players? 
  • The Core Mechanics – what are the mechanics that drive this game? Is there a core mechanic that forms a foundation for all the other rules, or are there dispersed rules covering different activities? How intuitive are the core mechanics? 
  • What is the Setting Doing? – Is the setting active (it takes a direct role in the game) or more passive (it is the flavoring for everything else)? Does the setting enforce the rules (and vice versa)? Is the setting facilitating the Core Loop? 

After I find those three things, I will work through the book in more detail. I will also take note of the page count for the various chapters. There is a correlation between page count and the importance of that chapter in the game.

Read a Published Adventure

Beyond the rules, I want to see at least one published adventure for this game (if they exist). If they don’t, then an example of play from the book will work, and beyond that, an actual play if neither exists. The published adventure does a few things. One, it shows me what the publishers think is important to have in your prep for running the game. It will show me how information should be presented, what stat blocks look like, how certain objectives are written out, etc. I can use/adapt this for my prep. 

The published adventure will also help me to see the core loop in action. Good published adventures cleave close to the core loop and become good examples of how to execute the core loop in play.

This and the rules define what the game needs. That lets me move outward to what I need. Starting with.. 

Setting Up Information Management and Workflow

With an understanding of the game and its core loop, I can start to work out my workflow for the game. I need to work through the three main areas of the game: 

  • Prep – I will first need to come up with a format for what the prep for a given session will look like. This usually comes in the form of a session outline with main headers, how I want to organize the session, etc. It will also consist of some formatting conventions, such as how to document NPCs’ stats, how I want to document dialog, etc. 
  • Campaign Management – I will then come up with how I want to catalog and track various campaign elements: NPCs, locations, factions/organizations, items, etc. For those, they may or may not need their own formats.
  •  Session Notes – I will then decide on how to capture any notes I take for the session, and more importantly, how to get them back into either the session prep or my campaign management system.   

As these three come together, I need to consider how information will flow to and from each one. This will become my workflow. Do details for an NPC get copied from Campaign Management to Prep? How do on-the-fly NPCs get into Campaign Management after a session? 

Mies En Place

The next thing I need to look at is how my GMing space will be arranged. A long time ago, I discussed this in an article here. 

What things will I need to have at my place at the table to run the game? Do I need some kind of initiative tracker? Do I need to keep track of tokens or minis? Do I have to track the loss of hit points from enemies? What rule references will I want during the game? 

Beyond the items I need, how will I arrange them at the table so that I have what I need at easy access? 

Setting The Table

Finally, what do we need as a group for running the game? Is this going to be a battlemat game or theater of the mind? Is there an online character tracker for the game, or should we use printed sheets? Does this game have reference tables, or do we need to find/make some? Do the players need access to a rulebook during play? Are we using music, SFX, or lighting?  Where will drinks and snacks go? 

Setting and Refinement

 Once I start playing the game, then I will see what works and does not, what is present and what is missing. Then comes the refinement. 

I will take all of this into consideration and come up with solutions for things before I get to the first game. That will all be my best guess based on what I read about the game. There is no substitute for actually playing the game. Once I start playing the game, then I will see what works and does not, what is present and what is missing. Then comes the refinement. I may need to adjust my prep format, or move where the initiative tracker goes on the table. I may need to change how to enter new NPCs into the Campaign Manager. 

After the basic needs are met is when we get into refining for efficiency. That will occur further into the campaign, after I have experience at prep, running, and managing. Then I will make tweaks for making things more efficient.

Planning Makes Perfect

The more comfortable you are with the rules, your information management, organization of your space as well as the table, the more comfortable you are going to be running your game. With some forethought and creativity, you can build yourself a system of play that serves all your needs as a GM, allowing you to better focus on telling great stories with you and your friends. 

How do you prepare for a new game? How much of your core setup remains from game to game, and how much do you re-invent each game?