- Gnome Stew - https://gnomestew.com -

To Sandbox or Not to Sandbox

[1]

The true sandbox stretches forever, with no signposts…

I don’t like sandboxes. Sand is coarse and rough and irritating — and it gets everywhere. Oh wait. Wrong kind of sand.

I hear those unfamiliar with the term asking, “But Ang, what is a sandbox game?” A sandbox game is one in which the GM has created a world that the players are allowed to explore at their discretion. If the GM has crafted any overarching plots or planted plot hooks, the players are completely free to ignore them to go where they want and do what they will. The term is also often used for video games like The Sims or Minecraft where the world is there for the player to interact with in whatever way they choose. Tabletop RPGs that use a sandbox model are theoretically the same, but still require other players and usually a GM.

My favorite games always have room for the PCs to affect the world, but it’s also clear that the GM regards the PCs as the main protagonists of the story the game play is creating.
I’ll be honest. I usually find sandbox games to be unsatisfying. Sometimes the games can be fun if there is the right combination of GM and other players, but the overall experience never lives up to the fun and enjoyment I’ve gotten out of more curated games. My favorite games always have room for the PCs to affect the world, but it’s also clear that the GM regards the PCs as the main protagonists of the story the game play is creating. I’m sure there are GMs capable of running a sandbox game that make that focus on the PCs happen, but my experiences always made me feel my character didn’t really matter in the grand scheme of things.

One of the common laments I’ve heard from sandbox GMs is that the players have ignored all of their plot hooks, so now they’re forced to rain down doom and destruction on the game world because the players didn’t stop the big bad that was actually doing stuff in the background. My pet peeve with this is that means the PCs are irrelevant to the world’s story. If the game’s story isn’t about the PCs, then why are we playing a roleplaying game?

To be fair, there are plenty of folks who love the sandbox style of game, and that is perfectly fine. I may not enjoy that style from the experiences I’ve had, but that doesn’t mean I’m going to tell someone else they’re having bad wrong fun for playing in a way that is outside of my preference. Everyone needs to find a game group that fits their tastes and needs for gaming, and if that happens to be a wide-open sandbox, then more power to you. Keep getting your game on however your group enjoys it.

Now that I’ve told you why I don’t like sandboxes, I’m going to confess that I found myself setting up my Savage Worlds East Texas University [6] campaign a bit like a sandbox.

“What?! Why on earth would you do that, Ang?”  Well, let me explain!

I suppose what I’m doing isn’t a true sandbox, but it feels like a good compromise between my relatively tighter campaigns and leaving things open ended. I still improvise the bits in between, but the players have their freedom to explore what their characters are interested in. Hell, our most recent session had me reconfigure a mystery to happen at a nearby Renaissance Festival because the players suddenly decided that was where they wanted to go.

What about you? What are your thoughts on sandbox games vs. the more curated style of campaign? Do most people fall somewhere in the middle? Do I think about this all a bit too much? GO RAVENS!

3 Comments (Open | Close)

3 Comments To "To Sandbox or Not to Sandbox"

#1 Comment By Chris On September 11, 2020 @ 11:45 am

I cannot recommend Dungeon World enough, if not as a great game in and of itself, but as a great resource on how to run a character and story-driven game with the flexibility of a sandbox game.

#2 Comment By ʄʀɨӄօֆƈօքɨօ On September 16, 2020 @ 10:03 pm

I’m with you about the sandboxes… Buuuut… 50 Fathoms 😛

#3 Comment By JiveScribe On September 28, 2020 @ 8:06 pm

This is such a helpful article for me! As a relatively new GM, who is just about to branch out into his first fully created World, many of these same questions about sandboxing were coming up in my mind naturally. A friend tipped me off to GnomeStew and so really glad to see so many awesome articles (including this one) that really help give perspective and solid information. I may be a newbie to roleplaying and GMing, but thanks for taking the time to make such a thoughtful article! Keep up the great work!