- Gnome Stew - https://gnomestew.com -

Asteroids, Dinosaurs, 5e, and Your Gaming Group

The most widely accepted theory as to what killed the dinosaurs is that an asteroid (maybe a comet) slammed into the Earth [1] about 65 million years ago. A big enough rock moving fast enough is all it took to obliterate the largest and fiercest creatures to have ever walked upon the surface of this planet.

Well asteroid Dungeons & Dragons 5th Edition [2] has been spotted and it has the potential to be an extinction event for many gaming groups. Unlike a Tyrannosaurus Rex though you probably have opposable thumbs and a chance at surviving this impact.

Track & Discuss

While a lot of gamers will be early adopters not everyone is going to switch to 5e. Maybe you are incredibly happy with the version of D&D that you currently play, or perhaps you do not play D&D at all. That is fine, but it will serve you well to keep an eye on what those maniacal wizards on the West coast are conjuring up even if you do not plan to play the game.

Why? It comes back to size and momentum. Wizards of the Coast is big enough to influence this industry on a scale that few organizations can, and they are getting the ball rolling with the open play testing model that has been announced. So while you may or may not be looking forward to this next generation of the iconic D&D game the rest of the people in your gaming group may have a very different plan than you do.

As a GM it cannot hurt to start talking now to the players in your game about the interest each member may or may not have in 5e. Do not ask them to choose if they will or will not play 5e. It is far too early to tell at this point, but do ask the people in your group what they think of the 5e announcement. You might get insightful feedback like “I hope that they fix the problems with combat being so long.” or maybe “I do not want to have to buy any new books.” These kinds of statements not only give you an idea of what your players want out of future D&D products, but it also gives you an insight into ways to improve your current game (i.e. – keep the combats short, and do not require more books based on the examples used).

Brace for Impact

As the 5e release draws closer and closer start gauging how it will effect your gaming group. If half of the players in your game cannot wait for its release while the other half refuses to even entertain the idea of playing 5e you will have a problem on your hands very soon. Detect it early and acknowledge it before it destroys your group with the madness that is known as the horror of “edition wars”.

Find out who is going to buy copies of the game and who will not. Measure your own interest in the product and determine what you plan on doing yourself. Will you buy the game the day it becomes available to the public, or will you wait for the reviews to come out first? You cannot make an informed decision at this time, but you can do your best to stay informed so that you can make one when the time comes.

Embrace the Change

Even if you do or do not switch to 5e yourself your group might change as a result of its release. Some players may leave the group to join a 5e game or to play a previous edition that they enjoy. At the same time you might absorb new players into your group from other groups feeling the aftershocks of 5e’s impact.

Just like there are still living descendants from the age of the dinosaurs in the form of crocodiles [3] and birds [4] your group can evolve and adapt to the presence of 5e when it arrives. Maybe your group will not alter in any way, or perhaps you will end up with a whole new game with players that you have just met, but as a GM you can benefit by acknowledging what the potential impact 5e can have on your group is.

Agree? Disagree? Got any tips of your own for dealing with the approach of 5e into your gaming world? Share your thoughts and ideas below in the form of a comment for all of us to read!

Want to provide anonymous feedback to me with the option to have me respond? Visit my SayAt.Me [5] page and have at it!

7 Comments (Open | Close)

7 Comments To "Asteroids, Dinosaurs, 5e, and Your Gaming Group"

#1 Comment By Kurt “Telas” Schneider On January 12, 2012 @ 10:14 am

I like your analogy. Change is coming; you can embrace it, resist it, or otherwise prepare for it. But ignoring it completely may leave you high and dry. (In gaming terms; nobody’s going extinct over this.)

#2 Comment By Scott Martin On January 12, 2012 @ 11:47 am

Even if you have no interest in it, their announcements may influence a lot of gaming chatter at your table. Especially if they point out a “fix” that doesn’t match your group’s play style at all…

#3 Comment By DarthKrzysztof On January 12, 2012 @ 12:38 pm

I’ve been running 4E online for awhile now, which has been frustrating. Real-world concerns have kept me from devoting much time to the campaign, so when the announcement came along, it was the excuse I’d been waiting for to kill the campaign.

But I’ve signed up for the playtest, and if and when we get to do that, we’ll revisit that campaign and those characters.

#4 Pingback By And here we go again… « Level 1 GM On January 12, 2012 @ 4:55 pm

[…] their eyes and stick their fingers in their ears than accept the fact that 5th Edition is coming. This article shows a good way of preparing yourself, and may persuade people to not join the tinfoil hat […]

#5 Comment By Patrick Benson On January 13, 2012 @ 2:53 pm

Thanks all! I am personally not really excited about the 5e announcement. I am sure that I will play the game at some point, but like Kurt said “ignoring it completely may leave you high and dry”.

#6 Comment By Gamerprinter On January 23, 2012 @ 3:46 pm

The only thing my players did when I told them 5e was announced was roll their eyes, which is pretty much my own reaction. In other words 5e will have the same impact 4e did – nothing. We play 3x or Pathfinder, WotC is no longer our go to game company, no matter how much money they have access to, no matter what new game they invent, our group is done with that company.

#7 Comment By Patrick Benson On January 23, 2012 @ 4:56 pm

[6] – Understood, but Pathfinder was the unintended consequence of decisions made by WotC that impacted Paizo’s business. You may avoid WotC, but Paizo is sure to make decisions and pursue initiatives in order to compete with WotC’s 5e product line. In that way you and your group may be indirectly impacted by 5e, and the article was meant to bring people’s attention to such potential events.

#8 Comment By Gamerprinter On January 24, 2012 @ 2:59 am


I am hopeful there’s some kind of OGL, so 3pps can participate, so no intent for harm to WotC, I hope they succeed and influence the industry, despite me not being a customer.